But, what if I were to tell you that none of that matters?
Let me clarify. Policies matter but there are a couple other (really important) items that we should square away before we go nitpicking over taxes and spending and other such things.
Here's our friend The Policy:
The problem is that policies aren't created in a vacuum. There is 'stuff' that comes along with it. A couple layers of really important stuff. Stuff that, if you put policies first tends to get put at risk. It's a delicate balance that is difficult to maintain .
So, what we end up with is something that looks like this:
|Hey, if the top layers crumble at|
least we have our policies, right?
It gets worse though. What we actually end up with is something that looks like this:
|Once this starts to tip, the whole|
mess comes tumbling down.
Either way, it's a precarious state. So by only looking at the policy part of the picture, what are you sacrificing? What's at risk because you're focused on a different part of the triangle?
- Rights & Freedoms
|The U.S. has one of these too. They're pretty serious|
about it, as anyone with one should be
Democracy is all the wonderful stuff that happens in a free society. In Canada at the federal level, it involves Parliament (the House of Commons) and the Senate (the Upper Chamber, a.k.a. the house of "sober second thought"). Members of Parliment (MPs) are elected and Senators are appointed by the Prime Minister. These are all the fine folks who create or change laws and draw up all those wonderful policies everyone is such a fan of. I've represented this as a layer called "Government":
This is how things shape up; the playing field for the most important game you're ever going to play:
Back in 2011 I blogged a lot about the election and I tried to keep a pretty even keel about it all. This time around things are different. Why? Because I've seen Canada's Charter disrespected too many times in the last 9 years to stay quiet any longer. Because I've seen our democracy whittled down to nothing. Because our foundation is cracked and our system is broken. Not all of that is the fault of the current government, but the lion's share of it is.
So, let's take a look at the PM and his band of merry Conservatives and see how they have treated the bottom two layers of that triangle - the important layers - the foundation of our free and democratic society.
- Look no further than their pathetic 8 losses and 2 "wins" in supreme court rulings. The National Post outlines 9 decisions here and The Georgia Straight highlights the latest
- And don't forget Stephen Harper's insulting treatment of Supreme Court Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin
Government / Democracy:
- The only Prime Minister to ever be found in contempt of Parliament
- Two separate Conservative convictions for improper election spending (2006 & 2008)
- Conservative conviction for election tampering in 2011
This would be a good time to pull out a quote from Stephen Harper himself. He said this of Liberal leader Jean Chrétien in the wake of the sponsorship scandal:
"He is the leader and a leader is responsible for the actions of the people he leads."Wow. If we put that statement to the test against the laundry list of crimes against democracy and Charter violations Mr. Harper has some explaining to do. The Conservatives have three separate convictions for crimes against our democratic system and Harper himself was found guilty of contempt of parliament. Now that's what I call leadership!
But it gets even better:
- The "fair" elections act. This gem actually makes it harder for people to vote and ties the hands of Elections Canada (oh, and takes polling station volunteer selection out of their hands altogether)
- Lack of meaningful debate and expert testimony for Bill C-51
- Massive omnibus bills - lumping in completely unrelated legislation in together. Two, in particular, were several hundred pages and involved over 100 different pieces of legislation
- Oh, let's not forget about the misuse and abuse of the Senate
Grade: FAILCan we just call the last 9 years a momentary lapse of reason?
Remember, all of the above should be considered before we even talk about a single policy. Quite frankly, a government that behaves this way is an insult to democracy and anyone who actually votes for it might as well look their children in the eye and say, "It's okay to be a bully so long as you get what you want in the end."
Wake up! The ends do not justify the means.
There is good news, though. If enough people vote together we can at least start rebuilding our democracy from a solid foundation. Elect a government that supports and encourages a strong, hard working democracy and it will implement policies that benefit Canada as a whole. Targeted policies implemented on top of a false democracy only benefit a privileged few. Maybe you're okay with that? I am not. I care too much about my neighbour to spit on his shoes and then lie right to his face and tell him it's raining.
Don't spit on your neighbours shoes. It's a really shitty thing to do and it's very un-Canadian.
Most of all, be careful. It's dangerous out there:
- LeadNow / Vote Together (Your best choice for who to vote for on October 19)
- CBC Vote Compass (Identify which political party you identify with on key issues)
- Three Hundred Eight (Political insight and analysis)
- NY Times Article "The Closing of the Canadian Mind"
- The Atlantic Article "The Case Against Stephen Harper"
- Harper's Assault on Democracy (Watchdog site)